Stephen Sizer: Hebrews 8-13

The Revd. Dr. Stephen Sizer is a man who believes malicious blogging (as defined by him, presumably) is a violation of the Eighth Commandment (in his Bible), and offers his own ten pieces of bull for Pastors to follow:

  1. Pastors should speak on the Eighth Commandment and its corollary injunctions against calumny and detraction;
  2. People should be warned that what they read on blogs is not necessarily true;
  3. Any anonymous blog or unsigned response has the weight of an unsigned letter and so should be quickly dismissed;
  4. A blog that is particularly vicious toward persons can be indicative of psychological illness, or simply an evil person, and is therefore suspect;
  5. Any blog that is unedifying and demeaning to another person should not be read. It is the equivalent of pornography;
  6. Responding to these calumnious blogs, even for defense of the individual or for clarification, only encourages the offender and prolongs the life of the calumny;
  7. Those who suffer calumny on anonymous blogs are, for the most part, better off enduring it. Seeking to correct misrepresentations usually has the effect of keeping controversy alive and adding to its interest value;
  8. While reading such blogs is damaging to its target (since it causes unwarranted negative speculation about another’s character), it also hurts the reader since it causes scandal, sowing pessimism and despondency;
  9. Calumnious blogging is a serious offense against God’s law. Those who engage in it are jeopardizing their immortal souls and the souls of others;
  10. For anyone to make a judgment concerning a person’s character based on what is read on a negative blog is to be a formal cooperator in the evil perpetrated by the blogger.

    As I discussed yesterday, Sizer appears to have posted what was equivalent to pornography on Living Journey, maintained by an Australian Christian blogger Vee; stating that Seismic Shock, another blogger had been cautioned by British Police for observing Sizer’s association with attested Holocaust Deniers and antisemites, as well as his own overtly anti-Judaic theology.

    But, there is more. In his most recent blog missive, Sizer invokes the story of the Christian Messiah’s approach to Jerusalem in discussing the separation barrier which brought a halt to wave-after-wave of Jew-murder attacks.

    It is ironic that if Jesus were born in Blackpool he would have no problem getting from Jericho to Jerusalem today. But because he was born in Bethlehem he would not be able to make the journey to the Mount of Olives, let alone join the Palm Sunday procession into the Old City. Like thousands of West Bank Christians he would be unable to visit Jerusalem today. He would be turned back at a military checkpoint – because he was born in Bethlehem.

    This is false witness, both as to why individuals would be refused access and as to the completeness of this refusal. It is also catachresis: irony does not mean paradoxical or unfortunate coincidence. Sizer’s co-complainant against Seismic Shock – the Rev. Dr. Anthony McRoy of the Wales Evangelical School of Theology – was being hugely ironic when he spoke of Christian charity whilst comparing Hezbollah’s pursuit and murder of Israeli Jews to Yehoshuan sacrifice: it is just that I do not feel like laughing.

    Sizer goes on:

    Dusty roads through dramatic scenery were as common then as now, indeed little has changed. Israeli checkpoints, barbed wire, military settlements and the Separation Barrier have replaced the Roman garrisons but it is still Occupied Territory.

    I suppose this updating of anti-Judaic polemics from the suggestions with pogroms at Eastertide from McRoy’s speech to a Khomenist theological skool to presenting Israeli Jews as the baddies of the Nativity Myth (as I discussed here) is a progression of sorts.

    Yet, it is not without its difficulties. First, just as with Sizer’s comparison of Christian Zionists to supporters of the Children of Hagar (Galatians 4:21/6) begs the question of what he thinks of Arabs in general and Arab Muslims specifically, there is the question of who he believes it was who Pax Romanica was oppressing in the region, and who rebelled.

    Hint, it was not the Christians.

    That said, I am not minded to call Sizer and McRoy antisemitic cunts.  The female pudenda is a wonderful and interesting object.

    UPDATE – Modernity speaks of the Barbara Streisand effect as this story is picked-up across the blogsphere. Bit unfortunate in view of Sizer’s suggested Sixth Rule of blogging.


    Tags: , , , ,

    11 Responses to “Stephen Sizer: Hebrews 8-13”

    1. We wish to show our solidarity with Seismic Shock who has been the victim of intimidation for shining a spotlight on the anti-Zionist theology of Reverend Stephen Sizer. | eChurch Christian Blog Says:

      […] efrafanday – Stephen Sizer: Hebrews 8-13 If you have stumbled onto this blog and are not a Christian, get yourself a hot drink, pull up a comfy chair and then tuck into the following article written by one of the best in the business:- All Of Grace by Charles Spurgeon […]

    2. Stuart Says:

      Linked. Great blog by the way, I have you firmly in my feedreader.

      • Alec Says:

        Cheers for that, Stuart. Incidentally, have you encountered another CofE anti-Israel polemicist, Ben White: an English lit graduate, he believes he’s more versed in theological argument than Patrick Sookdeo.

        Seismic discusses him and Sizer here

        • Stuart Says:

          What is the matter with them Alec, it beggars belief it really does…

        • Alec Says:

          White is a class act. At least Sizer is academically trained in the field and an engaging writer.

          After graduating from Cambridge c. 2002, White – reputably the son of a CofE vicar who’s not Sizer or West – went to live in Sao Paulo. During a period in which the local Police are estimated to have killed 11,000 people, he [White] trawled the Internet looking for articles to demonize Israel with and picking Sookdeo up on his theological arguments.

          Recently he described a sting operation against planned attacks on New York synagogues – and presumed Jew-murder – as “a fully controlled threat to our freedoms”. The response on his blog was extremely negative, and where he may have previously modified postive posts to highlight bits he agreed with, here he quickly closed the thread.

          What a competent blogger he is.

          Making his pennies stretch further in Brazil – presumably with services from the gutter-poor of the favelas – he lived in sight to the separation wall in *that* city, but – when I last checked – his Facebook profile picture was of that part of the Israeli separation barrier which is wall.

          This boy displays a worrying fixation, and at a book-launch recently was asked what his views were on the war-crimes in form of repeated mass-killings of Israeli civilians which the separation barrier halted in contrast to the legality of the barrier.

          “Whatever” was his reply.

          There are no sterile terms I can think of to describe this latest monstrous outgrowth of European anti-Judaism which doesn’t care for Arabs or Muslims as much as it wants to punish [the] Jews.

        • old Labour Says:

          Just to add to the above: White has recently returned from Sao Paolo to resettle in Britain. At least he is now only a quarter of a world away from his fixations.

          The common link here with White and Sizer is the pernicious Bethlehem Bible College, where White spent some ‘mission time’ the summer after he graduated, and where he turned himself into a self-proclaimed ‘expert’ on the Arab-Israeli conflict.

          The Bethlehem Bible College has become the leading centre for evangelical anti-Zionism since it was set up by Evangelical Arabs in 1979, led by a virulent Israel hater called Bishara Awad, and reputedly subsidised by the PLO. More on this institution here:

        • Alec Says:

          Cheers for that. There’s a contemporary Palestinian Arab Christian priest whose name is on the tip of my tongue… can you think?

          Naim something?

    3. Fabian from Israel Says:

      Jesus could not have been born in Bethlehem since no Jews can live there now and Jesus was a Jew. In fact, from the outskirts of Bethlehem, Palestinians Muslims fired upon Jews like Jesus living in Gilo.
      The simple things escape people like Sizer.

    4. Stephen Sizer, blogging and the Eighth Commandment « Seismic Shock Says:

      […] Stephen Sizer, blogging and the Eighth Commandment Filed under: censorship — seismicshock @ 8:28 pm At Efrafan Days. […]

    5. Ohtheirony Says:

      From p. 8 of Rev Sizer’s 2007 book “Zion’s Christian Soldiers”:

      “The battle over intellectual freedom is waged in universities on both sides of the Atlantic. Organisations such as Campus Watch and the Union of Jewish Students monitor staff and students and put pressure on the authorities to censure them.”

      You couldn’t make it up!!!

    Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

    You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


    Connecting to %s

    %d bloggers like this: